Return married Sarah Ann Wareham on 11 May 1664 in Windsor, Hartford, Connecticut, United States. Sarah was born on 28 Aug 1642 in Windsor, Hartford, Connecticut, British Colonial America; was christened in Windsor, Hartford, Connecticut, British Colonial America; died on 26 Dec 1678 in Northampton, Hampshire, Massachusetts Bay, British Colonial America; was buried in Dec 1678 in Palisado Cemetery, Windsor, Hartford, Connecticut, British Colonial America. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

Return married Margaret Newberry on 23 May 1689 in Windsor, Hartford, Connecticut, United States. Margaret was born on 23 Oct 1662 in Windsor, Hartford, Connecticut Colony, British Colonial America; died in Sep 1698 in Windsor, Hartford, Connecticut Colony, British Colonial America; was buried in Sep 1698 in Palsada Cemetery. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]