Plummer married Nancy Becton Joslin on 27 Jun 1835 in Davidson, Tennessee, United States. Nancy was born in 1821 in Tennessee, United States; died in 1851. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

Plummer married Susan Prichard on 19 Nov 1852 in Dickson, Tennessee, United States. Susan was born in 1808 in Tennessee, United States; died in 1875 in Dickson, Tennessee, United States; was buried in 1875 in Tennessee, United States. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]